India’s 3-0 victory over the Maldives came at a cost. Midfield playmaker Brandon Fernandes suffered a knee injury, ruling him out of the crucial match against Bangladesh. The 30-year-old was key in India’s long-awaited win, controlling the midfield with vision and creativity. His absence leaves coach Manolo Marquez with a tough decision, especially with Lallianzuala Chhangte, Manvir Singh, and Ashish Rai already injured.
With the Blue Tigers needing a new number 10, two names stand out. Naorem Mahesh Singh and Anirudh Thapa are strong contenders. But who is the best fit?
Naorem Mahesh Singh: A Like-for-Like Replacement?
Naorem Mahesh Singh was a constant threat against the Maldives. His versatility allows him to play multiple roles, making him a potential replacement for Brandon. Though inconsistent for East Bengal this season, Mahesh remains a dynamic player who can influence the game with dribbling and creative play.
His biggest strength is beating defenders in one-on-one situations, which could be crucial against Bangladesh. His off-ball movement also creates space for teammates. Additionally, he can take set-pieces, though not with the same precision as Fernandes.
Despite his talent, Mahesh’s finishing has been poor this season. In 20 ISL appearances (1,280 minutes), he has scored only two goals and registered one assist. His inconsistent form may worry Marquez, but his ability to drive forward makes him a strong candidate.
Anirudh Thapa: A Forgotten Asset?
Anirudh Thapa was left out of the national squad due to poor club form. Injuries have limited him to just 15 appearances (757 minutes) this season, with only two assists. His lack of game time under ATK Mohun Bagan coach Juan Ferrando has affected his rhythm, but his quality is undeniable.
Thapa offers something different compared to Mahesh. He may not score often, but his work rate, passing, and ability to dictate play make him valuable. His experience in high-pressure matches could also influence Marquez’s decision.
A key advantage Thapa has is his set-piece delivery. While not as precise as Fernandes, he can create goal-scoring opportunities. If fit, he could provide stability and creativity in midfield.
Who Should Marquez Choose?
With Brandon Fernandes out, Marquez must choose between Mahesh’s attacking flair and Thapa’s control. If he wants an aggressive approach, Mahesh’s dribbling and unpredictability could be key. If he prefers structure, Thapa’s experience and passing could be more effective.
India’s game plan against Bangladesh will determine the decision. If they need a direct attacking threat, Mahesh may get the nod. If they require a steady presence, Thapa might be the better choice. Either way, this is a chance for one of them to step up and make an impact.